After the dapp rating published by @therealwolf on [steemdapps](https://steemdapps.com/) and seeing @magicdice trx topping the chart, my interest increased in @magicdice. I then decided to play the game to evaluate if it is "provably fair " as claimed like all other online games of this nature. I played extensively for two days. And I observed that:

1. If you play small amount -then game  outcomes seem to be "random"
2. But if you consistently win or play large amount then game outcomes seem to be not "random"

So, to remove my doubt I decided to do the analysis of reported outcomes for my account. As per @magicdice post [Magic Dice Tech Talk - Provably fair and transparent](https://steemit.com/steemit/@magicdice/magic-dice-tech-talk-provably-fair-and-transparent), the serverhash used for any dice roll should have been published in advance onto the blockchain and I find that is the case. Have a look on below pictures:

![](https://cdn.steemitimages.com/DQmSvyqmY4UpfydSasNiFFMkYkSAtBdKwQJLpw7VPgFPcTu/image.png)

![](https://cdn.steemitimages.com/DQmNUo8jrUQtRjyxevxrYcLDNfM8DismSmKeGqMFsnskE2V/image.png)

![](https://cdn.steemitimages.com/DQmbBz8qN5QyyuPaUpPQrntdvQxAndwJRiPHqzeortwo3xv/image.png)

It clearly shows that @magicdice game is "provably fair" to this extent.

However, one issue still remains. And issue is @magicdice knows the serverseed. So they can use that information to predict the dice rolls and use that information to bet from some account. I would like @magicdice to make a comment on this that how do they put this loophole at rest.

You can signin and play [MagicDice using my referral link](https://magic-dice.com/?ref=prameshtyagi)