The fire in the cave, which had earlier seemed a small beacon of warmth and fragile hope, now seemed to cast long, dancing, almost accusatory shadows on the faces of the assembled survivors as Arthur Ainsworth’s words settled into the damp, smoky air. His proposal – to return to the island academy, that wellspring of their collective trauma, under a false identity, to somehow teach the “truth” to a new generation of unsuspecting Talents – hung between them, heavy, audacious, and bordering on the suicidally insane.

The silence that followed was profound, broken only by the incessant, indifferent roar of the waterfall outside and the sharp, sudden crackle of a log shifting in the flames. Arthur watched them, his own heart pounding a nervous rhythm against his ribs. He had laid it out, his desperate, improbable plan. He had endured their questions about his past, his origins, the unbelievable truth of his connection to their world. Now, this. He felt a familiar wave of English reserve, a sudden, almost overwhelming urge to apologize for having spoken at all, for having suggested something so clearly preposterous. Debating infiltration strategy for a secret government death school versus arguing over minor discrepancies in the petty cash tin back in the Crawley borough council office… a lifetime ago, on what felt like an entirely different, blessedly sane planet. Though even then, he mused with a flicker of grim internal humor, some of those protracted budget review meetings, especially on a bleak, rain-swept Tuesday afternoon, had felt like their own peculiar, soul-destroying form of psychological warfare. This, however, was several orders of magnitude beyond that.

It was Nana Hiiragi who finally broke the spell, her voice low, laced with a disbelief that bordered on horror. “Return?” she whispered, her violet eyes wide, fixed on Arthur as if he had sprouted a second head. “Arthur-san, you can’t be serious. Tsuruoka wants you _dead_. You said so yourself. He knows you’re an anomaly. Going back there, willingly walking back into that… that abattoir… it would be…” She trailed off, unable to voice the obvious conclusion.

“Extremely dangerous, yes, Hiiragi-san, I am acutely, painfully aware of that fundamental truth,” Arthur acknowledged, his voice quiet but firm. “I have no illusions about the personal risks involved.”

“The risks are not just personal, Ainsworth,” Kyouya Onodera interjected, his tone as cool and analytical as ever, though Arthur thought he detected a new, sharper edge of concern beneath the characteristic stoicism. “Your plan, while… bold… is predicated on a cascade of highly improbable variables. Creating a convincing new identity that can withstand even cursory Committee scrutiny? Fabricating academic qualifications that would allow you access as a teacher? Infiltrating their system without immediate detection by someone like Tsuruoka, who is already aware of your… unusual prior knowledge?” He shook his head slowly. “The logistical hurdles alone are monumental, perhaps insurmountable. And that’s before we even consider what you would do if you _did_ somehow succeed in gaining entry. How does one ‘teach the truth’ in such an environment without triggering every alarm, without immediately being identified and neutralized?”

Michiru Inukai, who had been listening with a growing expression of wide-eyed anxiety, finally spoke, her voice small and trembling. “Arthur-san… it’s… it’s too dangerous. Please. Isn’t there… isn’t there another way? A safer way for us to fight? Perhaps we could… try to find other escaped Talents? Build a community somewhere far away from here, somewhere they can’t find us?” Her plea was heartfelt, her gentle nature recoiling from the thought of Arthur deliberately placing himself in such mortal peril.

Arthur looked at Michiru, his heart aching at her innocent, desperate hope for a simple, peaceful solution. “I wish it were that easy, Michiru-san,” he said softly. “But Tsuruoka, The Committee… they won’t stop looking for us. For any of us. And they won’t stop their program on the island, or the new camps they are building. They will continue to find, to indoctrinate, to… _process_… Talented children. Hiding, surviving, it’s important, yes. But it won’t stop them. It won’t change anything fundamental.”

He turned back to the group. “Kyouya-san, your points are all valid. The risks are enormous. The chances of success, admittedly, are slim. But what is our alternative? Do we remain here, in this cave, in these mountains, for weeks, months, perhaps even years, always looking over our shoulders, gradually being hunted down one by one as Jin-san’s resources, his ability to shield us, inevitably dwindle? Is that a strategy for victory, or merely a plan for a slower, more protracted defeat?”

He saw Nana wince at his blunt assessment. She knew, better than anyone, the Committee’s relentless, unforgiving nature.

“My proposal,” Arthur continued, trying to keep the desperation from his voice, “is not without its severe flaws, I grant you. But its core objective – to reach the next generation of Talents _before_ they are fully indoctrinated, _before_ they are turned into weapons or victims, to plant the seeds of doubt, of critical thought, of resistance from _within_ one of their key institutions – that objective, I believe, is sound. It is a way to fight their lies directly, at the source.”

Jin Tachibana, who had remained a silent, unreadable observer throughout the exchange, finally spoke, his voice as smooth and cool as polished river stone. “The concept of ideological infiltration is a proven, if perilous, strategy, Ainsworth-san.” His pale eyes flicked towards Nana, then back to Arthur. “However, the specific target you propose – that particular island academy – is Tsuruoka’s personal fortress. It is where he forges his most dangerous assets. It will be guarded with a zealotry bordering on the fanatical, especially now, after the… recent embarrassments of our collective escape from his mainland facility, and Hiiragi-san’s subsequent, rather public, defiance.” He paused, a faint, almost imperceptible smile touching his lips. “Your chances of surviving such an endeavor, even with a flawless new identity, are, I would assess, statistically… negligible.”

“Perhaps,” Arthur conceded, his own internal Englishman recoiling at the sheer, almost cavalier understatement of Jin’s assessment. Negligible. Yes, that was probably about right. “But as I said…” He looked around at their grim, uncertain faces, at the firelight reflecting in their haunted eyes. “Anything we do now, anything meaningful, won’t be quick. And it certainly won’t be easy. Or safe.” He sighed, a deep, weary exhalation that seemed to carry the weight of his impossible, displaced years. “But something _needs_ to be done. We cannot simply let this stand. We cannot allow them to continue.”

He held their gazes, one by one, trying to convey the desperate sincerity, the grim resolve that underpinned his insane proposal. “So, that is my idea. My only idea, at present.” He spread his hands in a gesture of weary openness. “Unless, of course,” he repeated his earlier challenge, his voice quiet but firm in the sudden, renewed silence of the cave, “anyone else has any better ideas?”

The fire crackled again, the only sound for a long, tense moment. The weight of their situation, the sheer, overwhelming audacity of Arthur’s plan, and the stark, terrifying absence of any readily apparent, less suicidal alternatives, pressed down upon them all, a heavy, suffocating blanket of grim reality. The debate, Arthur knew, had only just begun.

[#talentless nana](https://www.tumblr.com/tagged/talentless%20nana)[#nana hiiragi](https://www.tumblr.com/tagged/nana%20hiiragi)[#munou na nana](https://www.tumblr.com/tagged/munou%20na%20nana)[#munounanana](https://www.tumblr.com/tagged/munounanana)[#nanahiiragi](https://www.tumblr.com/tagged/nanahiiragi)[#talentlessnana](https://www.tumblr.com/tagged/talentlessnana)[#無能なナナ](https://www.tumblr.com/tagged/%E7%84%A1%E8%83%BD%E3%81%AA%E3%83%8A%E3%83%8A)